Dollar Store Craft Hack – Custom Coffee Mugs

Over the past few weeks, I have been making crafts to donate to my church’s Home Sweet Home breakfast and silent auction.  As the co-chair of the event (my husband is the other co-chair), I want to make sure we have a great variety of beautiful crafts, as well as crafts that pair well with the donations from local businesses.  One local business that donated was CoffeeIcon, a local (and online) store that I absolutely love.  (I mean, you can try any K-Cup they have when you go in… a full sized, free cup of coffee just for going in!  And don’t get me started on how much I love the build-your-own K-Cup bar…)

Anyway, we have a donation of K-cups, fresh roasted coffee and a gift card for a coffee store, so I wanted to make a craft to go with it.  Custom coffee mugs!  And since we’re still on a really, really tight budget (*cough* check out my affiliate links *cough*), I wanted to make these awesome coffee mugs as inexpensively as possible.  So off to the dollar store I go!

I’m making two mugs and two bowls for each basket, to make a nice little breakfast set.  This technique is great because it works with any sort of dish: mugs, plate, bowls, butter dishes, whatever!  As long as it’s a ceramic dish (not glass or plastic), this will work.

Since this is a church event, one set has religiously themed sayings, and other is more “GIMME COFFEE!” themed.  Honestly, depending on the day, my mug could go either way!

Dollar Store Hack: Custom Coffee Mugs InstructionsPrepping the pattern for the custom Dollar Store Mug

  1. Create your design.  I’m still working on my hand-lettering skills, and I’m much better at designing graphics on my computer, so I opted to design a pattern to stencil on.  If the kids are doing it, let them freehand it.  They usually don’t have the patience for stenciling and tracing.  Make sure your design will fit on the side of your mug.  If you’re freehanding it, you can skip to step 3.
  2. Transfer the design.  I love the pencil-transfer method.  Color the back of the design heavily with pencil.  Then, tape it in place on the mug with the penciled side down.  Trace the pattern.  I like to trace the thick letters thicker so that I know when to really emphasize it and when to keep it simple.  Some people prefer to just do a simple trace and accent it later.  Either way, when you remove the pattern, the faint pencil lines will remain for you to trace.
  3. Decorate the dish.  Now is the artistic part.  Using oil based Sharpies, trace the pattern onto the mug.  If you’re not tracing, freehand draw on the mug with the oil-based Sharpies.  The oil-based Sharpies last much longer and are much more durable when it comes to washing that regular Sharpies.  I highly recommend getting a couple medium point markers for nice, fat strokes and at least one Extra-Fine Point Oil Based Sharpie Paint Pen in Black, for detailed text.  I kept it simple with just Silver and Gold Medium Point Oil Based Sharpie Paint Pens, but if the kids are doing it, I recommend more color.  The Medium Point Assorted Colors set is a great place to start.  If you’re doing this for the holidays, the Medium Point Oil Based Sharpie Paint Pens in Ice Colors is a great color palette to work with.  (Side note: my daughter made me a mug using the regular Sharpies, and we both loved it so much… but it faded so quickly, just with regular use and gentle hand washing.  It really broke her heart when it faded, so use Oil Based Sharpies!)
  4. final product of the dollar store painted mugs
    The final product! It’s a great motto…

    Bake the dish.  I played around with different baking times and temperatures when I’ve done this project before, and there’s a tricky medium between “baked long and hot enough that it’s durable” and “baked so long the color fades.”  The longer and hotter it bakes, the more durable it is, but the heat also fades colors.  I found that 300° for 2 hours is a good middle ground.  I place all of my dishes on a couple of cookie sheets so that I wouldn’t have to handle the super hot dishes when they came out.

  5. Let them cool.  Before you use them or wash them, let them cool at room temperature for a long time.  If you put them in cold water, you’ll shock them and they’ll break, so just let them cool on their own.
  6. Hand wash only! Even with the more durable oil based Sharpies, you’ll still want to be gentle with the final product.  Hand washing will help the paint last longer and keep your beautiful dishes lasting longer.

These mugs are great to take to work.  They remind you of something important to you (a personal mantra, your child’s artwork, etc.) and chances are you’ll be hand washing them at work instead of accidentally throwing them into the dishwasher when you’re distracted by a toddler hanging off of you… or trying to climb in.

So what is your mug mantra?  Share with us below!

Dollar Store Painted Mugs: The best tips and products to make them last!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *